Like us on Facebook

Please wait..10 Seconds Cancel
Showing posts with label Invalid Designation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Invalid Designation. Show all posts

Insurance Case Digest: Social Security System v. Davac (1966)

G.R. No. L-21642             July 30, 1966
Lessons Applicable: Invalid Designation (Insurance)

FACTS:
  • Petronilo Davac, a former employee of Lianga Bay Logging Co., Inc. became a member of the Social Security System (SSS) he designated Candelaria Davac as his beneficiary and indicated his relationship to her as that of "wife"
  • Lourdes Tuplano his legal wife and their son Romeo Davac and Candelaria Davac and their minor daughter Elizabeth Davac filed their claims
  • Social Security Commission: Candelaria Davac 
ISSUE: W/N Candelaria Davac can claim and New Civil Code 739 is not applicable

HELD: YES. 
  • she was not guilty of concubinage, there being no proof that she had knowledge of the previous marriage of her husband Petronilo
  • The amounts that may thus be received cannot be considered as property earned by the member during his lifetime
  • if there is a named beneficiary and the designation is not invalid (as it is not so in this case), it is not the heirs of the employee who are entitled to receive the benefits (unless they are the designated beneficiaries themselves). It is only when there is no designated beneficiaries or when the designation is void, that the laws of succession are applicable. And we have already held that the Social Security Act is not a law of succession. 

Insurance Case Digest: Southern Luzon Employees' Ass. v. Golpeo, et al. (1954)

G.R. No. L-6114      October 30, 1954
Lessons Applicable: Invalid Designation (Insurance)

FACTS:
  • Roman A. Concepcion listed as his beneficiaries Aquilina Maloles, Roman M. Concepcion, Jr., Estela M. Concepcion, Rolando M. Concepcion and Robin M. Concepcion for the death benefit of an association amounting to P2,505
  • Two sets of claimants presented themselves:
    • Juanita Golpeo, legal wife and her children, named beneficiaries by the deceased
      • Marcelino and Josefina Concepcion intervened in their own right aligning themselves Juanita Golpeo and her minor children
    • Elsie Hicban, another common law wife and her child
  • RTC:Aquilina Maloles and her children the sole beneficiaries
  • Only the Juanita Golpeo and her minor children and the intervenors Marcelino and Josefina Concepcion have appealed to this court
ISSUE: W/N Aquilina Molales common-law wife and her illegitimate children can claim the benefits

HELD:  YES.
  • Juanita Golpeo, by her silence and actions, had acquiesced in the illicit relations between her husband and appellee Aquilina Maloles
  • new Civil Code recognized certain successional rights of illegitimate children
Separate Opinions:
  • REYES, J.B.L., J., concurring
    • I concur in the result for the reason that the contract here involved was perfected before the new Civil Code took effect, and hence its provisions cannot be made to apply retroactively

Insurance Case Digest: Vda. Dde Consuegra v. Governments Service Insurance System (1971)

G.R. No. L-28093 January 30, 1971
Lessons Applicable: Invalid Designation (Insurance)

FACTS:
  • Jose Consuegra contracted two marriages.
    • First with Rosario Diaz
      • 2 children who predeceased their father: Jose Consuegra, Jr. and Pedro Consuegra
    • Second with Basilia Berdin while marriage is still subsisting
      • 7 children: Juliana, Pacita, Maria Lourdes, Jose, Rodrigo, Lenida and Luz, all surnamed Consuegra
  • Consuegra did not designate any beneficiary who would receive the retirement insurance benefits due to him
  • Rosario Diaz filed a claim with the GSIS asking that the retirement insurance benefits be paid to her as the only legal heir of Consuegra, considering that the deceased did not designate any beneficiary 
  • GSIS: legal heirs were Rosario Diaz (1/2 or 8/16), Basilia Berdin and their seven children (1/2 or 8/16) (1/16 each)
  • Basilia Berdin and her children filed petition for mandamus with preliminary injunction in CFI
  • RTC: dismissed the case
  • Basilia Berdin and her children appealed contending that because the deceased Jose Consuegra failed to designate the beneficiaries in his retirement insurance, the appellants who were the beneficiaries named in the life insurance should automatically be considered the beneficiaries to receive the retirement insurance benefits (Thus, excluding Rosario Diaz)
ISSUE: W/N the beneficiaries named in the life insurance should automatically be considered the beneficiaries to receive the retirement insurance benefits

HELD: NO. appealed from is affirmed
  • The insured in a life insurance may designate any person as beneficiary unless disqualified to be so under the provisions of the Civil Code
  • And in the absence of any beneficiary named in the life insurance policy, the proceeds of the insurance will go to the estate of the insured
  • Retirement insurance is primarily intended for the benefit of the employee — to provide for his old age, or incapacity, after rendering service in the government for a required number of years. If the employee reaches the age of retirement, he gets the retirement benefits even to the exclusion of the beneficiary or beneficiaries named in his application for retirement insurance. The beneficiary of the retirement insurance can only claim the proceeds of the retirement insurance if the employee dies before retirement.  If the employee failed or overlooked to state the beneficiary of his retirement insurance, the retirement benefits will accrue to his estate and will be given to his legal heirs in accordance with law, as in the case of a life insurance if no beneficiary is named in the insurance policy.
  • with respect to the right of the second wife, although the second marriage can be presumed to be void ab initio as it was celebrated while the first marriage was still subsisting, still there is need for judicial declaration of such nullity

Insurance Case Digest:The Insular Life Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Ebrado (1977)

G.R. No. L-44059 October 28, 1977
Lessons Applicable: 

  • Art. 2011 Civil Code (Insurance)
  • Invalid Designation (Insurance)

FACTS:
  • September 1, 1968: Buenaventura Cristor Ebrado was issued by The Insular Life Assurance Co., Ltd., Policy on a whole-life for P5,882.00 with a, rider for Accidental Death and designated Carponia T. Ebrado as the revocable beneficiary in his policy
  • October 21, 1969: Buenaventura was hit by a falling branch and died. 
  • Carponia filed a claim as the designated beneficiary, although she admits that they were merely living as husband and wife without the benefit of marriage
  • Pascuala Vda. de Ebrado also filed her claim as the widow of the deceased insured
  • In doubt as to whom the insurance proceeds shall be paid, the insurer, The Insular Life Assurance Co., Ltd. commenced an action for Interpleader bef. the CFI
  • CFI: Carponia was disqualified because of adultery
  • CA: affirmed CFI decision
ISSUE: W/N Carponia is disqualified for violating the Civil Code which supplements the silent Insurance Code.

HELD: YES. CA affirmed. 

Civil Code
Art. 2011
Art. 2011. The contract of insurance is governed by special laws. Matters not expressly provided for in such special laws shall be regulated by this Code. 
Art. 2012
Art. 2012. Any person who is forbidden from receiving any donation under Article 739 cannot be named beneficiary of a life insurance policy by the person who cannot make any donation to him, according to said article.
Art. 739
Art. 739. The following donations shall be void:

(1) Those made between persons who were guilty of adultery or concubinage at the time of the donation;
(2) Those made between persons found guilty of the same criminal offense, in consideration thereof;
(3) Those made to a public officer or his wife, descedants and ascendants, by reason of his office.

In the case referred to in No. 1, the action for declaration of nullity may be brought by the spouse of the donor or donee; and the guilt of the donor and donee may be proved by preponderance of evidence in the same action. 
  • Common-law spouses are, definitely, barred from receiving donations from each other
  • In essence, a life insurance policy is no different from a civil donation insofar as the beneficiary is concerned. Both are founded upon the same consideration: liberality. A beneficiary is like a donee, because from the premiums of the policy which the insured pays out of liberality, the beneficiary will receive the proceeds or profits of said insurance. As a consequence, the proscription in Article 739 of the new Civil Code should equally operate in life insurance contracts.
  • We do not think that a conviction for adultery or concubinage is exacted before the disabilities mentioned in Article 739 may effectuate.
  • requisite proof of common-law relationship between the insured and the beneficiary has been conveniently supplied by the stipulations between the parties in the pre-trial conference of the case