Like us on Facebook

Please wait..10 Seconds Cancel
Showing posts with label existing interest. Show all posts
Showing posts with label existing interest. Show all posts

Insurance Case Digest: Lampano v. Jose (1915)

G.R. No. L-9401   March 30, 1915
Lessons Applicable: Existing Interest (Insurance)
Laws Applicable: 

FACTS:

  • Mariano R. Barretto, constructed a house for Placida A. Jose sold the house to Antonina Lampano for P6,000 
  • The house was destroyed by fire during which Lampano still owed Jose P2,000 as evidenced by a promissory note.  Jose also owed Barretto P2,000 for the construction.
  • After the completion of the house and before it was destroyed, Mariano R. Barretto took out an insurance policy upon it in his own name, with the consent of Placida A. Jose, for the sum of P4,000. After its destruction, he collected P3,600 from the insurance company, having paid in premiums the sum of P301.50
  • Lampano filed a complaint against Barreto and Jose alleging that Jose in a verbal agreement told her that the policy will be delivered to her so she should collected P3,600 from each of them
  • RTC: favored Jose ordering Barreto to pay him P1,298.50 and offsetting the P2,000 
  • Barreto alone appealed
ISSUE: W/N Barreto had insurable interest in the house and could insure it for his it for his own protection

HELD: YES. reversed and Barretto is absolved

  • Where different persons have different interests in the same property, the insurance taken by one in his own right and in his own interest does not in any way insure to the benefit of another
  • A contract of insurance made for the insurer's (insured) indemnity only, as where there is no agreement, express or implied, that it shall be for the benefit of a third person, does not attach to or run with the title to the insured property on a transfer thereof personal as between the insurer and the insured. 
  • Barretto had an insurable interest in the house. He construed the building, furnishing all the materials and supplies, and insured it after it had been completed 

Insurance Case Digest: Ong Lim Sing v. FEB Leasing and Finance Corp. (2007)


G.R. No. 168115 June 8, 2007

Lessons Applicable: Existing Interest (Insurance)
Laws Applicable: 

FACTS:

  • FEB Leasing and Finance Corporation (FEB) leased equipment and motor vehicles to JVL Food Products with a monthly rental of P170,494
  • At the same date, Vicente Ong Lim Sing, Jr. (Lim) an executed an Individual Guaranty Agreement with FEB to guarantee the prompt and faithful performance of the terms and conditions of the lease agreement
  • JVL defaulted in the payment of the monthly rentals resulting to arrears of  P3,414,468.75 and refused to pay despite demands
  • FEB filed a complaint for damages and replevin against JVL, Lim and John Doe
    • JVL and Lim admitted the existence of the lease agreement but asserted that it is in reality a sale of equipment on installment basis, with FEB acting as the financier
  • RTC: Sale on installment and the FEB elected full payment of the obligation so for the unreturned units and machineries the JVL and Lim are jointly and severally liable to pay
  • CA: granted FEB appeal that it is a financial lease agreement under Republic Act  (R.A.) No. 8556 and ordered JVL and Lim jointly and severally to pay P3,414,468.75
ISSUE: W/N JVL and Lim should jointly and severally be liable for the insured financial lease

HELD: YES. CA affirmed.

  • contract of adhesion is as binding as any ordinary contract
  • The Lease Contract with corresponding Lease Schedules with Delivery and Acceptance Certificates is, in point of fact, a financial lease within the purview of R.A. No. 8556
    • FEB leased the subject equipment and motor vehicles to JVL in consideration of a monthly periodic payment of P170,494.00.  The periodic payment by petitioner is sufficient to amortize at least 70% of the purchase price or acquisition cost of the said movables in accordance with the Lease Schedules with Delivery  and  Acceptance  Certificates.
  • JVL entered into the lease contract with full knowledge of its terms and conditions.  
  • Lim, as a lessee, has an insurable interest in the equipment and motor vehicles leased.  
  • In the financial lease agreement, FEB did not assume responsibility as to the quality, merchantability, or capacity of the equipment.  This stipulation provides that, in case of defect of any kind that will be found by the lessee in any of the equipment, recourse should be made to the manufacturer.  “The financial lessor, being a financing company, i.e., an extender of credit rather than an ordinary equipment rental company, does not extend a warranty of the fitness of the equipment for any particular use.  Thus, the financial lessee was precisely in a position to enforce such warranty directly against the supplier of the equipment and not against the financial lessor.  We find nothing contra legem or contrary to public policy in such a contractual arrangement

Insurance Case Digest: Gaisano Cagayan, Inc. v. Insurance Company of North America (2006)


G.R. No. 147839             June 8, 2006

Lessons Applicable: Existing Interest (Insurance)
Laws Applicable: Article 1504,Article 1263, Article 2207 of the Civil Code, Section 13 of Insurance Code
 
FACTS:

  • Intercapitol Marketing Corporation (IMC) is the maker of Wrangler Blue Jeans. while Levi Strauss (Phils.) Inc. (LSPI) is the local distributor of products bearing trademarks owned by Levi Strauss & Co
  • IMC and LSPI separately obtained from Insurance Company of North America fire insurance policies for their book debt endorsements related to their ready-made clothing materials which have been sold or delivered to various customers and dealers of the Insured anywhere in the Philippines which are unpaid 45 days after the time of the loss
  • February 25, 1991: Gaisano Superstore Complex in Cagayan de Oro City, owned by Gaisano Cagayan, Inc., containing the ready-made clothing materials sold and delivered by IMC and LSPI was consumed by fire. 
  • February 4, 1992: Insurance Company of North America filed a complaint for damages against Gaisano Cagayan, Inc. alleges that IMC and LSPI filed their claims under their respective fire insurance policies which it paid thus it was subrogated to their rights
    • Gaisano Cagayan, Inc: not be held liable because it was destroyed due to fortuities event or force majeure
  • RTC: IMC and LSPI retained ownership of the delivered goods until fully paid, it must bear the loss (res perit domino)
  • CA: Reversed - sales invoices is an exception under Article 1504 (1) of the Civil Code to res perit domino
ISSUE: W/N Insurance Company of North America can claim against Gaisano Cagayan for the debt that was isnured

HELD: YES. petition is partly GRANTED. order to pay P535,613 is DELETED

  • insurance policy is clear that the subject of the insurance is the book debts and NOT goods sold and delivered to the customers and dealers of the insured
  • ART. 1504. Unless otherwise agreed, the goods remain at the seller's risk until the ownership therein is transferred to the buyer, but when the ownership therein is transferred to the buyer the goods are at the buyer's risk whether actual delivery has been made or not, except that:

    (1) Where delivery of the goods has been made to the buyer or to a bailee for the buyer, in pursuance of the contract and the ownership in the goods has been retained by the seller merely to secure performance by the buyer of his obligations under the contract, the goods are at the buyer's risk from the time of such delivery;
  • IMC and LSPI did not lose complete interest over the goods. They have an insurable interest until full payment of the value of the delivered goods. Unlike the civil law concept of res perit domino, where ownership is the basis for consideration of who bears the risk of loss, in property insurance, one's interest is not determined by concept of title, but whether insured has substantial economic interest in the property
  • Section 13 of our Insurance Code defines insurable interest as "every interest in property, whether real or personal, or any relation thereto, or liability in respect thereof, of such nature that a contemplated peril might directly damnify the insured." Parenthetically, under Section 14 of the same Code, an insurable interest in property may consist in: (a) an existing interest; (b) an inchoate interest founded on existing interest; or (c) an expectancy, coupled with an existing interest in that out of which the expectancy arises. 
  • Anyone has an insurable interest in property who derives a benefit from its existence or would suffer loss from its destruction.
    • it is sufficient that the insured is so situated with reference to the property that he would be liable to loss should it be injured or destroyed by the peril against which it is insured
    • an insurable interest in property does not necessarily imply a property interest in, or a lien upon, or possession of, the subject 
    • matter of the insurance, and neither the title nor a beneficial interest is requisite to the existence of such an interest
  • insurance in this case is not for loss of goods by fire but for petitioner's accounts with IMC and LSPI that remained unpaid 45 days after the fire - obligation is pecuniary in nature
    • obligor should be held exempt from liability when the loss occurs thru a fortuitous event only holds true when the obligation consists in the delivery of a determinate thing and there is no stipulation holding him liable even in case of fortuitous event
  • Article 1263 of the Civil Code in an obligation to deliver a generic thing, the loss or destruction of anything of the same kind does not extinguish  the obligation (Genus nunquan perit)
  • The subrogation receipt, by itself, is sufficient to establish not only the relationship of respondent as insurer and IMC as the insured, but also the amount paid to settle the insurance claim
  • Art. 2207. If the plaintiff's property has been insured, and he has received indemnity from the insurance company for the injury or loss arising out of the wrong or breach of contract complained of, the insurance company shall be subrogated to the rights of the insured against the wrongdoer or the person who has violated the contract. 
  • As to LSPI, no subrogation receipt was offered in evidence. 
    • Failure to substantiate the claim of subrogation is fatal to petitioner's case for recovery of the amount of P535,613

Insurance Case Digest: Filipino Merchants Insurance Co. v. CA (1989)


G.R. No. 85141   November 28, 1989

Lessons Applicable: Existing Interest (Insurance)
Laws Applicable: Article 1523 of the Civil Code,Section 13 of the Insurance Code
 
FACTS:

  • Choa Tiek Seng, consignee of the shipment of fishmeal loaded, insured in "all risks policy" 600 metric tons of fishmeal in new gunny bags of 90 kilos each from Bangkok, Thailand to Manila against all risks under warehouse to warehouse terms but only 59.940 metric tons was imported 
  • When it was unloaded unto the arrastre contractor E. Razon, Inc. and Filipino Merchants's surveyor ascertained and certified that in such discharge 105 bags were in bad order condition which was reflected in the survey report of Bad Order cargoes
  • Before delivery to Choa, E. Razon's Bad Order Certificate showed that a total of 227 bags in bad order condition
  • Choa brought an action against Filipino Merchants Insurance Co. who brought a third party complaint against  Compagnie Maritime Des Chargeurs Reunis and/or E. Razon, Inc.
  • RTC: Ordered Filipino Merchants to pay Choa and reimbursefrom Compagnie Maritime Des Chargeurs Reunis and third party defendant E. Razon, Inc.
  • CA: Affirmed but modified by adjudicating the third party complaint
    • Filipino Merchants contended that Chao has no insurable interest and therefore the policy should be void and that it was fraud that it did not disclose of such fact 
ISSUE: W/N Choa Tiek Seng as consignee of the shipment has insurable interest

HELD: YES. CA affirmed.

  • GR: the burden of proof is upon the insured to show that a loss arose from a covered peril, but under an "all risks" policy the burden is not on the insured to prove the precise cause of loss or damage for which it seeks compensation. The insured under an "all risks insurance policy" has the initial burden of proving that the cargo was in good condition when the policy attached and that the cargo was damaged when unloaded from the vessel; thereafter, the burden then shifts to the insurer to show the exception to the coverage. - none was shown = liable
  • Section 13 of the Insurance Code defines insurable interest in property as every interest in property, whether real or personal, or any relation thereto, or liability in respect thereof, of such nature that a contemplated peril might directly damnify the insured.
  • As vendee/consignee of the goods in transit has such existing interest. His interest over the goods is based on the perfected contract of sale. The perfected contract of sale between him and the shipper of the goods operates to vest in him an equitable title even before delivery or before be performed the conditions of the sale.  The contract of shipment, whether under F.O.B., C.I.F., or C. & F. as in this case, is immaterial in the determination of whether the vendee has an insurable interest or not in the goods in transit.
  • Article 1523 of the Civil Code provides that where, in pursuance of a contract of sale, the seller is authorized or required to send the goods to the buyer, delivery of the goods to a carrier, whether named by the buyer or not, for, the purpose of transmission to the buyer is deemed to be a delivery of the goods to the buyer, the exceptions to said rule not obtaining in the present case. The Court has heretofore ruled that the delivery of the goods on board the carrying vessels partake of the nature of actual delivery since, from that time, the foreign buyers assumed the risks of loss of the goods and paid the insurance premium covering them
  • C & F contracts are shipment contracts. The term means that the price fixed includes in a lump sum the cost of the goods and freight to the named destination. It simply means that the seller must pay the costs and freight necessary to bring the goods to the named destination but the risk of loss or damage to the goods is transferred from the seller to the buyer when the goods pass the ship's rail in the port of shipment.  
  • Moreover, the issue of lack of insurable interest was not among the defenses averred in petitioners answer. 

Insurance Case Digest: Traders Insurance & Surety Co. v. Golangco, et al (1954)

G.R. No. L-6442    Sep 21, 1954
Lessons Applicable: Existing Interest (Insurance)
Laws Applicable: Sec. 13 of the Insurance Code 


FACTS:
  • Tomas Lianco and the Archbishop entered into a contract of lease on a parcel of landowned by church 
  • As lessee, Lianco erected a building on the leased portion of the church’s land. 
  • Lianco transferred ownership of this building to Kaw Eng Si,who later transferred the same to Golangco.
    • Transfers were made without the consent of the Archbishop
  • The Archbishop filed an ejectment case against Lianco, who appears to be occupants of the premises building with others paying rent to Golangco.
    • The right of Golangco to receive rent on the building was judicially recognized in a case decided between Lianco and others occupying the premises pursuant to a compromise agreement.
  • The Archbishop did not exercise his option to question Golangco’s rights as lessee
  • April 7,1949: Golangco applied for fire insurance with Trader’s Insurance and Surety Co. 
    • fire insurance policy states: "that all insurancecovered under said policy, includes the 'rent or othersubject matter of insurance in respect of or inconnection with any building or any property contained in any building"
  • June 5, 1949: the building premises was burned so  Golangco requested Trader’s Insurance to pay the insurance amount of 10,000 including the amount of rent P1,100 monthly. 
    • Trader’s insurance refused to pay the insurance for the rent averring that Golangco has no insurable interest 
ISSUE: W/N Golangco has insurable interest on the rent of the building premises which may lawfully/validly be subject of insurance?

HELD: YES.
  • Sec. 13 of the Insurance Code 
Every interest in the property, whether real or personal, or any relation thereto, or liability in respect thereof of such nature that a contemplated peril might directly damnify the insured, is an insurable interest.
  • Both at the time of the issuance of the policy and at the time of the fire, Golangco was in legal possession of the premises, collecting rentals from its occupant.
  • The argument of Trader’s Insurance that a policy of insurance must specify the interest of the insured in the property insured, if he is not the absolute owner thereof, is not meritorious because it was the Trader’s, not Golangco, who prepared that policy, and it cannot take advantage of its own acts to plaintiff's detriment; and, in any case, this provisionwas substantially complied with by Golangco when he made a full and clear statement of his interests to Trader's manager.  
    • The contract between Lianco and the Archbishop only forbade Lianco from transferring 'his rights as LESSEE but the contracts Lianco made in favor of Kaw Eng Siand plaintiff Golangco did not transfer such rights; hence no written consent thereto was necessary. At worst, the contract would be voidable, but not a void contract, at the option of the Archbishop and it does not appear that it was ever exercised