Like us on Facebook

Please wait..10 Seconds Cancel
Showing posts with label Ambiguous Provisions Interpreted Against Insurer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ambiguous Provisions Interpreted Against Insurer. Show all posts

Insurance Case Digest: Del Rosario v. Equitable Ins. and Casualty Co., Inc. (1963)

G.R. No. L-16215            June 29, 1963
Lessons Applicable: Ambiguous Provisions Interpreted Against Insurer (Insurance)

FACTS:
  • April 13, 1957: Simeon del Rosario, father of the insured who died from drowning filed a claim for payment with Equitable Ins. and Casualty Co., Inc. but it refused to pay more than P1,000 php so a case was filed with the RTC for the P2,000 balance stating that under the policy they are entitled to P1,000 to P3,000 as indemnity
  • RTC: entitled to recover P3,000 - policy does not positively state any definite amount, there is an ambiguity in this respect in the policy, which ambiguity must be interpreted in favor of the insured and strictly against the insurer so as to allow greater indemnity
ISSUE: W/N Simeon is entitled to recover P3,000 

HELD: YES.
  • terms in an insurance policy, which are ambiguous, equivocal or uncertain are to be construed strictly against, the insurer, and liberally in favor of the insured so as to effect the dominant purpose of indemnity or payment to the insured, especially where a forfeiture is involved
  • reason for this rule is that the "insured usually has no voice in the selection or arrangement of the words employed and that the language of the contract is selected with great care and deliberation by expert and legal advisers employed by, and acting exclusively in the interest of, the insurance company

Insurance Case Digest: Qua Chee Gan v. Law Union and Rock Insurance Co., Ltd. (1955)

G.R. No.L-4611        December 17, 1955
Lessons Applicable: Ambiguous Provisions Interpreted Against Insurer (Insurance)

FACTS:
  • Qua Chee Gan, a merchant of Albay, owned four bodegas which he insured with Law Union & Rock Insurance Co., Ltd (Law Union) since 1937 and the lose made payable to the Philippine National Bank (PNB) as mortgage of the hemp and crops, to the extent of its interest
  • July 21, 1940 morning: fire broke out in bodegas 1,2 and 4 which lasted for almost a week. 
    • Qua Chee Gan informed Law Union by telegram
  • Law Union rejected alleging that it was a fraudulent claim that the fire had been deliberately caused by the insured or by other persons in connivance with him
  • Que Chee Gan, with his brother, Qua Chee Pao, and some employees of his, were indicted and tried in 1940 for the crime of arson but was  subsequently acquitted
  • During the pendency of the suit, Que Chee Gan paid PNB
  • Law Union states that ff. assignment of errors:
    • 1. memo of warranty requires 11 hydrants instead of 2 
    • 2. violation of hemp warranty against storage of gasoline since it prohibits oils
    • 3. fire was due to fraud
    • 4. burned bodegas could not possibly have contained the quantities of copra and hemp stated in the fire claims
ISSUE: W/N Qua Chee Gan should be allowed to claim.

HELD: YES. Affirmed.
  • 1. It is a well settled rule of law that an insurer which with knowledge of facts entitling it to treat a policy as no longer in force, receives and accepts a preium on the policy, estopped to take advantage of the forfeiture
  • 2. oils (animal and/or vegetable and/or mineral and/or their liquid products having a flash point below 300o Fahrenheit", and is decidedly ambiguous and uncertain; for in ordinary parlance, "Oils" mean "lubricants" and not gasoline or kerosene
    • by reason of the exclusive control of the insurance company over the terms and phraseology of the contract, the ambiguity must be held strictly against the insurer and liberraly in favor of the insured, specially to avoid a forfeiture
  • 3. trial Court found that the discrepancies were a result of the insured's erroneous interpretation of the provisions of the insurance policies and claim forms, caused by his imperfect knowledge of English, and that the misstatements were innocently made and without intent to defraud.
  • 4. Similarly, the 20 per cent overclaim on 70 per cent of the hemo stock, was explained by the insured as caused by his belief that he was entitled to include in the claim his expected profit on the 70 per cent of the hemp, because the same was already contracted for and sold to other parties before the fire occurred