Like us on Facebook

Please wait..10 Seconds Cancel
Showing posts with label Authority to Receive Payment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Authority to Receive Payment. Show all posts

Insurance Case Digest: South Sea Surety and Insurance Co., Inc. v. CA (1995)

G.R. No. 102253  June 2, 1995
Lessons Applicable: 

  • Authority to Receive Payment/Effect of Payment (Insurance)
  • Binding Effect of Payment (Insurance)
Laws Applicable: Section 77,Section 301, Section 306 of the Insurance Code

FACTS:

  • Valenzuela Hardwood and Industrial Supply, Inc. shipped with Seven Brothers' vessel M/V Seven Ambassador lauan round logs numbering 940 at the port of Maconacon, Isabela for shipment to Manila
  • Valenzuela insured the logs against loss and/or, damage with South Sea Surety and Insurance Co., Inc. for P2,000,000 issuing a Marine Cargo Insurance Policy
  • January 24 1984: Valenzuela gave the check in payment of the premium on the insurance policy to Mr. Victorio Chua
  • January 25 1984: M/V Seven Ambassador sank
  • January 30 1984: The check was tendered to South Sea but it refused.  Instead it cancelled the insurance policy for non-payment of the premium
  • RTC: favored Valenzuela against South Sea and Seven Brothers
  • CA: Absolved Seven Brothers 
    • stipulation in the charter party that the ship owner would be exempted from liability in case of loss 
  • South Sea contends that it is cancelled and that Mr. Chua is not authorized
ISSUE: W/N  Mr. Chua is an authorized representative to receive the payment

HELD: YES. petition is DENIED

  • payment of the premium is a condition precedent to, and essential for, the efficaciousness of the contract.
    • The only two statutorily provided exceptions are 
      • (a) in case the insurance coverage relates to life or industrial life (health) insurance when a grace period applies and 
      • (b) when the insurer makes a written acknowledgment of the receipt of premium, this acknowledgment being declared by law to be then conclusive evidence of the premium payment
  • South Sea Surety and Insurance Co., Inc. delivered to him the policy on 21 January 1984 at his office to be delivered to the Valenzuela - deemed to have been authorized by the South Sea Surety and Insurance Co., Inc. to receive the premium