Like us on Facebook

Please wait..10 Seconds Cancel
Showing posts with label Public humiliation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Public humiliation. Show all posts

Torts and Damages Case Digest: Rafael Patricio v. Hon. Oscar Leviste, et al., (1989)

G.R. No. L-51832 April 26, 1989
Lessons Applicable: Public humiliation (Torts and Damages)
Laws Applicable: ART. 2219,Art. 21, Art. 23

FACTS:

  • May 16, 1976 10 pm: During a benefit dance in celebration of the town fiesta Rafael Patricio, an ordained Catholic priest together with 2 policemen were posted near the gate of the public auditorium to check on the assigned watchers of the gate.  
  • Bienvenido Bacalocos, President of the Association of Barangay Captains of Pilar, Capiz and a member of the Sangguniang Bayan who was in the state of drunkenness was also at the same gate struck a bottle of beer on the table which injured and caused his own hand to bleed.  
  • Bacalocos then approached Patricio and asked him if he has seen his wounded hand and before Patricio could respond he hit Patricio's face with his bloodied hand.
  • Bacalocos was brought to the Police Station
  • Patricio filed a criminal case charging Bacalocos for Slander by Deed but it was dismissed so he filed for damages in the court a quo. 
  • Court a quo: liable for moral damages as a result of the physical suffering, moral shock and social humiliation 
  • Motion for reconsideration: Court reconsidered moral and exemplary damages, in order to merit, the plaintiff ought to have proven actual or compensatory damages
    • Patricio: Being slapped in public causing him physical suffering and social humiliation, entitles him to moral damages; Actual and compensatory damages need not be proven
ISSUE: W/N Patricio should be entitled to moral damages

HELD:YES. petition is GRANTED. CA REVERSED and court a quo REINSTATED

  • ART. 2219. Moral damages may be recovered in the following and analogous cases

(1)    A criminal offense resulting in physical injuries;

(2)    Quasi-delicts causing physical injuries;

(3)    Seduction, abduction, rape, or other lascivious acts.

(4)    Adultery or concubinage;

(5)    Illegal or arbitrary detention or arrest;

(6)    Illegal search;

(7)    Libel, slander or any other form of defamation;

(8)    Malicious prosecution;

(9)    Acts mentioned in article 309;

(10)  Acts and actions referred to in articles 21, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 32, 34, and 35.
  • The hitting on the face is contrary to morals and good customs and causing mental anguish, moral shock, wounded feelings and social humiliation
  • drunkenness is definitely no excuse and does not relieve him of his liability
  • Pursuant to Art. 21 of the Civil Code in relation to par. (10) of Art. 2219 of the same Code, "any person who wilfully causes loss or injury to another in a manner that is contrary to morals, good customs or public policy shall compensate the latter for the damage
  • under Art. 21 of the Civil Code is to compensate the injured party for the moral injury caused upon his person
  • ART. 23.    Any person who wilfully causes loss or injury to another in a manner that is contrary to morals, good customs or public policy shall compensate the latter for the damage.
  • Exemplary or corrective damages are required by public policy to suppress the wanton acts of the offender
    • The amount of exemplary damages need not be proved where it is shown that plaintiff is entitled to either moral, temperate or compensatory damages, as the case may be
    • such award cannot be recovered as a matter of right
  • In cases where exemplary damages are awarded to the injured party, attorney's fees are also recoverable

Torts and Damages Case Digest: Grand Union Supermarket et al., v. Jose J. Espino, Jr., et al., (1979)


G.R. No. L-48250 December 28, 1979

Lessons Applicable: Public humiliation (Torts and Damages)
Laws Applicable: Articles 19 and 21 in relation to Article 2219 of the Civil Code, Art. 26,Art. 2214, New Civil Code

FACTS:

  • Jose J. Espino. Jr., a civil engineer and an executive of Procter and Gamble Philippines, Inc, together with his wife and two daughters went to shop at South Supermarket in Makati
  • Finding a cylindrical "rat tail" file which he needed for his hobby, he picked it up and held it fearing it might get lost because of its tiny size
  • While shopping, they saw the maid of Jose's aunt so as he talked, he placed the rat tail in his breast pocket partly exposed 
  • At the check-out counter, he paid for their purchases worth P77 but forgot to pay the file
  • As he was exiting the supermarket, he was approached by Guard Ebreo regarding the file in his pocket.  He quickly apologized saying "I'm Sorry" and he turned towards the cashier to pay.  But, he was stopped and instead was brought to the rear of the supermarket when he was asked to fill out an Incident Report labeling him as "Shoplifter"
  • His wife joined him since he was taking so long and they were brought to the first checkout counter where Ms. Nelia Santos-Fandino's desk was.  She made a remark:"Ano, nakaw na naman ito".  Jose told Ms. Fandino that he was going to pay for the file because he needed it but she replied "That is all they say, the people whom we cause not paying for the goods say... They all intended to pay for the things that are found to them."
  • Jose objected stating he is a regular customer of the supermarket
  • He gave P5 to pay for the P3.85 cost of the file but Ms. Fandino said the P5 was his fine which will be rewarded to the guard.  People were staring at them.  He took the file and paid the file at the nearest checkout counter with P50 and got out as fast as they could.  His first impulse was to go back to the supermarket that night to throw rocks at its glass windows. But reason prevailed over passion and he thought that justice should take its due course.
  • He filed against Grand Union Supermarket et al. founded on Article 21 in relation to Article 2219 of the New Civil Code and prays for moral damages, exemplary damages, attorney s fees and 'expenses of litigation, costs of the suit and the return of the P5 fine
  •  CFI: dismissed
  • CA: reversed and granted damages of P75,000 by way of moral damages, P25,000 as exemplary damages, and P5,000 as attorney's fee
ISSUE: W/N Grand Union Supermarket should be liable for public humiliation founded on Article 21 in relation to Article 2219 of the New Civil Code

HELD: YES. Grand Union Supermarket ordered to pay, jointly and severally moral damages P5,000 and P2,000 as and for attorney's fees; and to return the P5 fine

  • Jose did not intend to steal the file and that is act of picking up the file from the open shelf was not criminal nor done with malice or criminal intent for on the contrary, he took the item with the intention of buying and paying for it
    • personal circumstances:
      • graduate Mechanical Engineer from U.P. Class 1950, employed as an executive of Proctor & Gamble Phils., Inc., a corporate manager incharge of motoring and warehousing therein; honorably discharged from the Philippine Army in 1946; a Philippine government pensionado of the United States for six months; member of the Philippine veterans Legion; author of articles published in the Manila Sunday Times and Philippines Free Press; member of the Knights of Columbus, Council No. 3713; son of the late Jose Maria Espino, retired Minister, Department of Foreign Affairs at the Philippine Embassy Washington
  • Jose was falsely accused of shoplifting is evident
  • Fine branding him as a thief which was not right nor justified
  • the mode and manner in which he was subjected, shouting at him, imposing upon him a fine, threatening to call the police and in the presence and hearing of many people at the Supermarket which brought and caused him humiliation and embarrassment, sufficiently rendered the petitioners liable for damages under Articles 19 and 21 in relation to Article 2219 of the Civil Code
  • It is against morals, good customs and public policy to humiliate, embarrass and degrade the dignity of a person
    • Everyone must respect the dignity, personality, privacy and peace of mind of his neighbors and other persons (Article 26, Civil Code)
  • His forgetfullness led to his embarassment and humiliation thereby causing him mental anguish, wounded feelings and serious anxiety. His act of omission contributed to the occurrence of his injury or loss and such contributory negligence is a factor which may reduce the damages that private respondent may recover (Art. 2214, New Civil Code). Moreover, that many people were present and they saw and heard the ensuing interrogation and altercation appears to be simply a matter of coincidence in a supermarket which is a public place and the crowd of onlookers, hearers or bystanders was not deliberately sought or called by management to witness private respondent's predicament.
  • Grand Union Supermarket  acted in good faith in trying to protect and recover their property, a right which the law accords to them. - eliminate the grant of exemplary damages