Like us on Facebook

Please wait..10 Seconds Cancel
Showing posts with label Bill of Lading. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bill of Lading. Show all posts

Transportation Case Digest: Samar Mining Co., Inc. v. Nordeutcher Lloyd, et. al.(1984)

G.R. No. L-28673 October 23, 1984
Lessons Applicable: Bill of Lading (Transportation)
Laws Applicable: Article 1736, Article 1738,Article 1884,Article 1889,Article 1892,Article 1909

FACTS:
  • Samar Mining Company, Inc. imported1 crate of welded wedge wire sieves shipped through Nordeutscher Lloyd
    • Bill of Lading No. 18:
      • transshipped at port of discharge: davao
      • Section 1, paragraph 3 of Bill of Lading No. 18
        • The carrier shall not be liable in any capacity whatsoever for any delay, loss or damage occurring before the goods enter ship's tackle to be loaded or after the goods leave ship's tackle to be discharged, transshipped or forwarded ...
        • Section 11:
          • Whenever the carrier or m aster may deem it advisable or in any case where the goods are placed at carrier's disposal at or consigned to a point where the ship does not expect to load or discharge, the carrier or master may, without notice, forward the whole or any part of the goods before or after loading at the original port of shipment, ... This carrier, in making arrangements for any transshipping or forwarding vessels or means of transportation not operated by this carrier shall be considered solely the forwarding agent of the shipper and without any other responsibility whatsoever even though the freight for the whole transport has been collected by him. ... Pending or during forwarding or transshipping the carrier may store the goods ashore or afloat solely as agent of the shipper and at risk and expense of the goods and the carrier shall not be liable for detention nor responsible for the acts, neglect, delay or failure to act of anyone to whom the goods are entrusted or delivered for storage, handling or any service incidental thereto 
  • When the goods arrived in the port of Davao, it was delivered in good order and condition to the bonded warehouse of AMCYL but it was not delivered and received by Samar Mining Company, Inc.
  • Samar filed a claim against Nordeutscher and C.F. Sharp who brought in AMCYL as third party defendant
  • RTC: favored Samar
    • Nordeutscher and C.F. Sharp laible but may enforce judgment against AMCYL
ISSUE: W/N the stipulations in bills of lading exempting the carrier from liability for loss or damage to the goods when the same are not in its actual custody is valid

HELD: YES. Reversed

  • Article 1736.       The extraordinary responsibility of the common carrier lasts from the time the goods are unconditionally placed in the possession of, and received by the carrier for transportation until the same are delivered, actually or constructively, by the carrier to the consignee, or to the person who has a right to receive them, without prejudice to the provisions of article 1738. - applicable
  • Article 1738.       The extraordinary liability of the common carrier continues to be operative even during the time the goods are stored in a warehouse of the carrier at the place of destination, until the consignee has been advised of the arrival of the goods and has had reasonable opportunity thereafter to remove them or otherwise dispose of them. - no applicable since article contemplates a situation where the goods had already reached their place of destination and are stored in the warehouse of the carrier
  • Article 1884.       The agent is bound by his acceptance to carry out the agency, and is liable for the damages which, through his non-performance, the principal may suffer.
  • Article 1889.       The agent shall be liable for damages if, there being a conflict between his interests and those of the principal, he should prefer his own.
  • Article 1892.       The agent may appoint a substitute if the principal has not prohibited him from doing so; but he shall be responsible for the acts of the substitute:

    (1)    When he was not given the power to appoint one;

    (2)    When he was given such power but without designating the person and the person appointed was notoriously incompetent or insolvent
  • Article 1909.       The agent is responsible not only for fraud, but also for negligence which shall be judged with more or less rigor by the courts, according to whether the agency was or was not for a compensation.
  • The records fail to reveal proof of negligence, deceit or fraud committed by appellant or by its representative in the Philippines. Neither is there any showing of notorious incompetence or insolvency on the part of AMCYT, which acted as appellant's substitute in storing the goods awaiting transshipment

Transportation Case Digest: Magellan Mfg. Marketing Corp. v. CA supra (1991)

G.R. No. 95529   August 22, 1991

Lessons Applicable: Bill of Lading (Transportation)
Laws Applicable: 

FACTS:

  • Choju Co., Ltd purchased from Magellan Manufacturers Marketing Corp. (MMMC) 136,000 anahaw fans for $23,220
  • MMMC contracted with F.E. Zuellig, a shipping agent of Orient Overseas Container Lines, Inc., (OOCL) specifying that he needed an on-board bill of lading and that transhipment is not allowed under the letter of credit 
  • MMMC paid F.E. Zuellig the freight charges and secured a copy of the bill of lading which was presented to Allied Bank. The bank then credited the amount of US$23,220 covered by the letter of credit to MMMC
  • When MMMC's President James Cu, went back to the bank later, he was informed that the payment was refused by the buying for lack of bill of lading and there was a transhipment of goods
  • The anahaw fans were shipped back to Manila through OOCL who are demanding from MMMC P246,043.43 (freight charges from Japan to Manila, demurrage incurred in Japan and Manila from October 22, 1980 up to May 20, 1981 and charges for stripping the container van of the Anahaw fans on May 20, 1981)
  • MMMC abandoned the whole cargo and asked OOCL for damages
    • OOCL: bill of lading clearly shows that there will be a transhipment and that petitioner was well aware that MV (Pacific) Despatcher was only up to Hongkong where the subject cargo will be transferred to another vessel for Japan
  • RTC: favored OOCL:
    • consented because the bill of lading where it is clearly indicated that there will be transhipment
    • MMMC was the one who ordered the reshipment of the cargo from Japan to Manila
  • CA: Affirmed with modification of excluding demurrage in Manila
ISSUE: W/N the bill of lading which reflected the transhipment against the letter of credit is consented by MMMC 

HELD: YES. CA Affirmed with modification

  • Transhipment
    • act of taking cargo out of one ship and loading it in another
    • the transfer of goods from the vessel stipulated in the contract of affreightment to another vessel before the place of destination named in the contract has been reached
    • transfer for further transportation from one ship or conveyance to another
  • the fact of transhipment is not dependent upon the ownership of the transporting ships or conveyances or in the change of carriers, as the petitioner seems to suggest, but rather on the fact of actual physical transfer of cargo from one vessel to another
  • appears on the face of the bill of lading the entry "Hong Kong" in the blank space labeled "Transhipment," which can only mean that transhipment actually took place
  • bill of lading 
    • operates both as a receipt and as a contract
      • receipt for the goods shipped
      • contract to transport and deliver the same as therein stipulated 
        • names the parties, which includes the consignee, fixes the route, destination, and freight rates or charges, and stipulates the rights and obligations assumed by the parties
        • law between the parties who are bound by its terms and conditions provided that these are not contrary to law, morals, good customs, public order and public policy
  • GR: acceptance of the bill without dissent raises the presumption that all the terms therein were brought to the knowledge of the shipper and agreed to by him and, in the absence of fraud or mistake, he is estopped from thereafter denying that he assented to such term
  • There clearly appears on the face of the bill of lading under column "PORT OF TRANSHIPMENT" an entry "HONGKONG'
  • On board bill of lading vs. received for shipment bill of lading:
    • on board bill of lading
      • stated that the goods have been received on board the vessel which is to carry the goods
    • received for shipment bill of lading 
      • stated that the goods have been received for shipment with or without specifying the vessel by which the goods are to be shipped
      • issued whenever conditions are not normal and there is insufficiency of shipping space
  • certification of F.E. Zuellig, Inc. cannot qualify the bill of lading, as originally issued, into an on board bill of lading as required by the terms of the letter of credit issued in favor of petitioner - it is a received for shipment bill of lading 
    • issued only on July 19, 1980, way beyond the expiry date of June 30, 1980 specified in the letter of credit for the presentation of an on board bill of lading 
  • Demurrage
    • compensation provided for in the contract of affreightment for the detention of the vessel beyond the time agreed on for loading and unloading
    • claim for damages for failure to accept delivery
  • before it could be charged for demurrage charges it should have been notified of the arrival of the goods first
  • Since abandon option was communicated, the same is binding upon the parties on legal and equitable considerations of estoppel