Like us on Facebook

Please wait..10 Seconds Cancel
Showing posts with label conflict of law case digest. Show all posts
Showing posts with label conflict of law case digest. Show all posts

Conflicts of Law Case Digest: Northwest Orient Airlines, Inc. v. CA (1995)

G.R. No. 112573  February 9, 1995
Lessons Applicable: Territoriality Principle (conflicts of law)

FACTS:
  • Northwest Airlines (Northwest) and C.F. Sharp & Company (C.F.), through its Japan branch, entered into an International Passenger Sales Agency Agreement, whereby the Northwest authorized the C.F. to sell its air transportation tickets
  • March 25, 1980: Unable to remit the proceeds of the ticket sales, Northwest sued C.F. in Tokyo, Japan, for collection of the unremitted proceeds of the ticket sales, with claim for damages
  • April 11, 1980: writ of summons was issued by the 36th Civil Department, Tokyo District Court of Japan
    • The attempt to serve the summons was unsuccessful because Mr. Dinozo was in Manila and would be back on April 24, 1980
  • April 24, 1980: Mr. Dinozo returned to C.F. Office to serve the summons but he refused to receive claiming that he no longer an employee
  • After the 2 attempts of service were unsuccessful, Supreme Court of Japan sent the summons together with the other legal documents to the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Japan> Japanese Embassy in Manila>Ministry (now Department) of Foreign Affairs of the Philippines>Executive Judge of the Court of First Instance (now Regional Trial Court) of Manila who ordered Deputy Sheriff Rolando Balingit>C.F. Main Office
  • August 28, 1980:  C.F. received from Deputy Sheriff Rolando Balingit the writ of summons but failed to appear at the scheduled hearing. 
  • January 29, 1981: Tokyo Court rendered judgment ordering the C.F. to pay 83,158,195 Yen and damages for delay at the rate of 6% per annum from August 28, 1980 up to and until payment is completed
  • March 24, 1981: C.F. received from Deputy Sheriff Balingit copy of the judgment. C.F. did not appeal so it became final and executory
  • May 20, 1983: Northwest filed a suit for enforcement of the judgment a RTC
  • July 16, 1983: C.F. averred that the Japanese Court sought to be enforced is null and void and unenforceable in this jurisdiction having been rendered without due and proper notice and/or with collusion or fraud and/or upon a clear mistake of law and fact. The foreign judgment in the Japanese Court sought in this action is null and void for want of jurisdiction over the person of the defendant considering that this is an action in personam.  The process of the Court in Japan sent to the Philippines which is outside Japanese jurisdiction cannot confer jurisdiction over the defendant in the case before the Japanese Court of the case at bar
  • CA sustained RTC: Court agrees that if the C.F. in a foreign court is a resident in the court of that foreign court such court could acquire jurisdiction over the person of C.F. but it must be served in the territorial jurisdiction of the foreign court
ISSUE: W/N the Japanese Court has jurisdiction over C.F.

HELD: YES. instant petition is partly GRANTED, and the challenged decision is AFFIRMED insofar as it denied NORTHWEST's claims for attorneys fees, litigation expenses, and exemplary damages
  • Consequently, the party attacking (C.F.) a foreign judgment has the burden of overcoming the presumption of its validity
  • Accordingly, the presumption of validity and regularity of the service of summons and the decision thereafter rendered by the Japanese court must stand.
  • Applying it, the Japanese law on the matter is presumed to be similar with the Philippine law on service of summons on a private foreign corporation doing business in the Philippines. Section 14, Rule 14 of the Rules of Court provides that if the defendant is a foreign corporation doing business in the Philippines, service may be made: 
    • (1) on its resident agent designated in accordance with law for that purpose, or, 
    • (2) if there is no such resident agent, on the government official designated by law to that effect; or 
    • (3) on any of its officers or agents within the Philippines.
    • If the foreign corporation has designated an agent to receive summons, the designation is exclusive, and service of summons is without force and gives the court no jurisdiction unless made upon him. 
    • Where the corporation has no such agent, service shall be made on the government official designated by law, to wit: 
      • (a) the Insurance Commissioner in the case of a foreign insurance company
      • (b) the Superintendent of Banks, in the case of a foreign banking corporation
      • (c) the Securities and Exchange Commission, in the case of other foreign corporations duly licensed to do business in the Philippines. Whenever service of process is so made, the government office or official served shall transmit by mail a copy of the summons or other legal proccess to the corporation at its home or principal office. The sending of such copy is a necessary part of the service.
  • The service on the proper government official under Section 14, Rule 14 of the Rules of Court, in relation to Section 128 of the Corporation Code
  • Our laws and jurisprudence indicate a purpose to assimilate foreign corporations, duly licensed to do business here, to the status of domestic corporations
  • We think it would be entirely out of line with this policy should we make a discrimination against a foreign corporation, like the petitioner, and subject its property to the harsh writ of seizure by attachment when it has complied not only with every requirement of law made specially of foreign corporations, but in addition with every requirement of law made of domestic corporations
  • In as much as SHARP was admittedly doing business in Japan through its four duly registered branches at the time the collection suit against it was filed, then in the light of the processual presumption, SHARP may be deemed a resident of Japan, and, as such, was amenable to the jurisdiction of the courts therein and may be deemed to have assented to the said courts' lawful methods of serving process.
  • Accordingly, the extraterritorial service of summons on it by the Japanese Court was valid not only under the processual presumption but also because of the presumption of regularity of performance of official duty. 

Conflict of Laws Digest: Phil. Export and Foreign Loan Guarantee Corp. v. V.P. Eusebio Construction Inc. (2004)

G.R. No. 140047           March 31, 2003
Lessons Applicable: No conflicts rule on essential validity of contracts (conflicts of law)

FACTS:
  • November 8, 1980: State Organization of Buildings (SOB), Ministry of Housing and Construction, Baghdad, Iraq, awarded the construction of the Institute of Physical Therapy–Medical Rehabilitation Center, Phase II, in Baghdad, Iraq, (Project) to Ajyal Trading and Contracting Company (Ajyal), a firm duly licensed with the Kuwait Chamber of Commerce for ID5,416,089/046 (or about US$18,739,668)
  • March 7, 1981: 3-Plex International, Inc. represented by Spouses Eduardo and Iluminada Santos a local contractor engaged in construction business, entered into a joint venture agreement with Ajyal.   However since it was not accredited under the Philippine Overseas Construction Board (POCB), it had to assign and transfer all its right to VPECI. 
  • VPECI entered into an agreement that the execution of the project will be under their joint management.
  • To comply with the requirements of performance bond of ID271,808/610 and an an advance payment bond of ID541,608/901, 3-Plex and VPECI applied for the issuance of a guarantee with Philguarantee, a government financial institution empowered to issue guarantees for qualified Filipino contractors to secure the performance of approved service contracts abroad. 
  • Subsequently, letters of guarantee were issued by Philguarantee to the Rafidain Bank of Baghdad. Al Ahli Bank of Kuwait was, therefore, engaged to provide a counter-guarantee to Rafidain Bank, but it required a similar counter-guarantee in its favor from the Philguarantee
  • The Surety Bond was later amended to increase the amount of coverage from P6.4 million to P6.967 million and to change the bank in whose favor the petitioner's guarantee was issued, from Rafidain Bank to Al Ahli Bank of Kuwait
  • SOB and the joint venture VPECI and Ajyal executed the service contract for the construction of the Institute of Physical Therapy – Medical Rehabilitation Center, Phase II, in Baghdad, Iraq.  It commenced only on the last week of August 1981 instead of the June 2 1981
  • Prior to the deadline, upon foreseeing the impossibility to meet it, the surety bond was also extended for more than 12 times until May 1987 and the Advance Payment Guarantee was extended three times more until it was cancelled for reimbursement 
  • On 26 October 1986, Al Ahli Bank of Kuwait sent a telex call to the petitioner demanding full payment of its performance bond counter-guarantee
  • VPECI requested Iraq Trade and Economic Development Minister Mohammad Fadhi Hussein to recall the telex call on the performance guarantee for being a drastic action in contravention of its mutual agreement that (1) the imposition of penalty would be held in abeyance until the completion of the project; and (2) the time extension would be open, depending on the developments on the negotiations for a foreign loan to finance the completion of the project.
    • VPECI advised the Philguarantee not to pay yet Al Ahli Bank because efforts were being exerted for the amicable settlement of the Project
    • VPECI  received another telex message from Al Ahli Bank stating that it had already paid to Rafidain Bank the sum of US$876,564 under its letter of guarantee, and demanding reimbursement by Philguarantee
  • VPECI requested the Central Bank to hold in abeyance the payment by the Philguarantee "to allow the diplomatic machinery to take its course, for otherwise, the Philippine government , through the Philguarantee and the Central Bank, would become instruments of the Iraqi Government in consummating a clear act of injustice and inequity committed against a Filipino contractor
  • Central Bank authorized the remittance to Al Ahli Bank
  • Philguarantee informed VPECI that it would remit US$876,564 to Al Ahli Bank, and reiterated the joint and solidary obligation of the respondents to reimburse the Philguarantee for the advances made on its counter-guarantee but they failed to pay so a case was filed in the RTC
  • RTC and CA: Against Philguarantee since no cause of action since it was expired because VPECI. Inequity to allow the Philguarantee to pass on its losses to the Filipino contractor VPECI which had sternly warned against paying the Al Ahli Bank and constantly apprised it of the developments in the Project implementation.
ISSUE: W/N the Philippine laws should be applied in determining VPECI's default in the performance of its obligations under the service contract

HELD: YES.
  • No conflicts rule on essential validity of contracts is expressly provided for in our laws
    • The rule followed by most legal systems, however, is that the intrinsic validity of a contract must be governed by the lex contractus or "proper law of the contract." This is the law voluntarily agreed upon by the parties (the lex loci voluntatis) or the law intended by them either expressly or implicitly (the lex loci intentionis) - none in this case
  • In this case, the laws of Iraq bear substantial connection to the transaction, since one of the parties is the Iraqi Government and the place of performance is in Iraq. Hence, the issue of whether respondent VPECI defaulted in its obligations may be determined by the laws of Iraq. However, since that foreign law was not properly pleaded or proved, the presumption of identity or similarity, otherwise known as the processual presumption, comes into play. Where foreign law is not pleaded or, even if pleaded, is not proved, the presumption is that foreign law is the same as ours
  • In the United States and Europe, the two rules that now seem to have emerged as "kings of the hill" are (1) the parties may choose the governing law; and (2) in the absence of such a choice, the applicable law is that of the State that "has the most significant relationship to the transaction and the parties  Another authority proposed that all matters relating to the time, place, and manner of performance and valid excuses for non-performance are determined by the law of the place of performance or lex loci solutionis, which is useful because it is undoubtedly always connected to the contract in a significant way
  • In this case, the laws of Iraq bear substantial connection to the transaction, since one of the parties is the Iraqi Government and the place of performance is in Iraq. Hence, the issue of whether respondent VPECI defaulted in its obligations may be determined by the laws of Iraq. However, since that foreign law was not properly pleaded or proved, the presumption of identity or similarity, otherwise known as the processual presumption, comes into play. Where foreign law is not pleaded or, even if pleaded, is not proved, the presumption is that foreign law is the same as ours
  • delay or the non-completion of the Project was caused by factors not imputable to the respondent contractor such as the war in Iraq
  • petitioner as a guarantor is entitled to the benefit of excussion, that is, it cannot be compelled to pay the creditor SOB unless the property of the debtor VPECI has been exhausted and all legal remedies against the said debtor have been resorted to by the creditor. It could also set up compensation as regards what the creditor SOB may owe the principal debtor VPECI.  In this case, however, the petitioner has clearly waived these rights and remedies by making the payment of an obligation that was yet to be shown to be rightfully due the creditor and demandable of the principal debtor.

Conflict of Laws Digest: Bank of America v. CA (2003)

G.R. No. 120135           March 31, 2003
Lessons Applicable: forum non conveniens (conflicts of laws)

FACTS:

  • Eduardo K. Litonjua, Sr. and Aurelio J. Litonjua (Litonjuas) were engaged in the shipping business owning 2 vessels: Don Aurelio and El Champion
  • Because their business where doing well, Bank of America (BA) offered them to take a loan for them to increase their ships.  
  • BA acquired through them as borrowers four more ships: (a) El Carrier; (b) El General; (c) El Challenger; and (d) El Conqueror.  The registration, operation, income, funds, possession of the vessel belonged to the corporation.
  • May 10, 1993: Litonjuas filed a complaint to the RTC Pasig claming that during its operations and the foreclosure sale, BA as trutees failed to fully render an account of the income.  They lost all their 6 vessels and 10% of their personal funds and they still have an unpaid balance of their loans.
  • BA NT&SA, and BA international filed a Motion to Dismiss on grounds of forum non conveniens and lack of cause of action against them
  • RTC and CA: Dismissed
ISSUE: 
1. W/N there is grounds of forum non conveniens
2. W/N there is litis pendentia

HELD: Denied

1. NO.
  • The doctrine of forum non-conveniens, literally meaning 'the forum is inconvenient', emerged in private international law to deter the practice of global forum shopping
  • Under this doctrine, a court, in conflicts of law cases, may refuse impositions on its jurisdiction where it is not the most "convenient" or available forum and the parties are not precluded from seeking remedies elsewhere.
  • Whether a suit should be entertained or dismissed on the basis of said doctrine depends largely upon the facts of the particular case and is addressed to the sound discretion of the trial court.
  • Philippine Court may assume jurisdiction over the case if it chooses to do so; provided, that the following requisites are met: 
    • (1) that the Philippine Court is one to which the parties may conveniently resort to; - present
    • (2) that the Philippine Court is in a position to make an intelligent decision as to the law and the facts; and, - present
    • (3) that the Philippine Court has or is likely to have power to enforce its decision - present
  • This Court further ruled that while it is within the discretion of the trial court to abstain from assuming jurisdiction on this ground, it should do so only after vital facts are established, to determine whether special circumstances require the court's desistance; and that the propriety of dismissing a case based on this principle of forum non conveniens requires a factual determination, hence it is more properly considered a matter of defense
2. NO.
  • litis pendentia to be a ground for the dismissal of an action there must be:
    • (a) identity of the parties or at least such as to represent the same interest in both actions -present
    • (b) identity of rights asserted and relief prayed for, the relief being founded on the same acts - not shown
    • (c) the identity in the two cases should be such that the judgment which may be rendered in one would, regardless of which party is successful, amount to res judicata in the other - not shown
  • It merely mentioned that civil cases were filed in Hongkong and England